Overall Score - 9.5 / 10
Scare Factor - 9.5
Actors - 9
Visuals - 9.5
Value - 10

Gayle - So, this was my first visit here.  I have been unable to come years prior due to scheduling conflicts, as much was the case this year...BUT...I cancelled some things and moved others around just to come. And was I glad I did! This place is super cool! It's pretty much an exact 2 hour drive from Cincinnati, and worth every minute. Pulling into the parking spot, people are greeted with an almost club-ish feel...flashing lights, fog, pumping music...tons of people in line dancing and chatting. Inside, this place is visually pretty incredible. It almost has this underground cavern feel until you exit the elevator. Each room you enter is spacious and very open,  leaving visitors feeling quite vulnerable as actors can literally come from every direction! The props and scenes were so detailed, and realistic!  Just some of my favorites were the electrified fence, (a great effect), as was the swamp, prison area, and the amazing village outside.  So very well done! There were so many amazing actors here, and some quite freaky costumes, combined with the overall dynamic and energy of this haunt has now made this one a must see every year! I loved it so much, and had so much fun that I wanted to immediately walk back through! LOVED IT...and definitely worth the trip!​

Teresa - I love Fear Fair! You feel like you're going into the middle of nowhere and you must be lost, but trust me, it is worth the trip to Seymour. It is in a warehouse district near an airport. You see the lights when you get close. A dee-jay was spinning some good creepy tunes with some party lights and fog effects. This provides ample entertainment for the line. I was a little disappointed to not see any roaming queue actors this year, but the zombie dee-jay is really all you need. This is one of the few attractions where you can experience a full-contact haunt. You have the option to carry a glow-stick if you don't want to be touched. No one in our group wanted one, we like to get up close and personal with our monsters! The line was quite long, and for an extra $10 you can skip the line. This is a good option if you're in a hurry. They have half price tickets for Halloween night too! You can have a group photo taken once you get inside, which makes a good souvenir. You start off by getting into an elevator which is supposed to take you to the 16th floor, but it goes very wrong! You wind up in this sub-level that looks like a cave. There are many memorable scenes here. One of my favorites is the swamp. There is also a really cool cemetery with some impressive props! New this year they built a set that looks like it is out of the movie, The Witch, complete with a Black Phillip-like character. It was a really impressive set, complete with barnyard smells. Some of the actors were really great! The zombies that kept trying to bite me were so creepy! And the Silent Hill section is still my favorite. It is staged so well! We saw Pyramid Head from a distance, which gave us plenty of time to dread what was coming. Then we saw one of the nurses, suspended along the wall. Yikes! We were walking along a fence, and Pyramid Head was following along the other side when he got me in the leg with his big knife through a hole in the fence! I definitely didn't see that coming! He grabbed the guy leading our group, which was awesome! The actors were so much fun. One grabbed me and made someone in my group pay to get me back. I was worth a whole nickel, by the way. Another guy was on a bungee cord and jumped right at us. Talk about jump scares! I was grabbed a few times, but it wasn't too aggressive. At the end, we were separated into guys and girls, with each going through a different door. Then there was a clever use of a 2-way mirror so you can see each other being terrified. I won't spoil the surprise though. I was also tagged in the neck with a chainsaw. This place will definitely get your adrenaline going! The one thing I missed from last year was the zombie attacks. That section is now the Witch set, but the zombies last year were more aggressive. We had lots of laughs when they ran out of their hiding spots and jumped on us! That being said, this is still one of my favorites and I look forward to seeing them build on it every year. This place is so much fun and worth every penny!

Paul - Who would guess that one of the best haunts in the region would be in a small town in the middle of nowhere Indiana? 

Seymour, IN is a little town off of I-65, halfway between Indianapolis and Louisville, KY. The only thing I've ever really known about Seymour is that it's the hometown of John Mellencamp. Sorry John, but Fear Fair takes your spot as my favorite part of Seymour.

Fear Fair is located in a business park next to the small airport on the south side of town. The area is completely deserted during the haunt's operating hours, so if you think you're in the wrong place when you try to find it, just stick with your GPS and you'll get there. There aren't really any signs pointing to where you need to go, but when you get close you'll start to notice the flashing lights and hear the music from the DJ. You'll definitely know when you've arrived once you see what looks like a rave happening in front of you- even if you don't exactly know where to park. (We've been twice and just kind of park wherever we see other cars. I'm still not sure if they have an official parking area or not.)

Once you arrive, the tickets are sold out of a big military truck of some sort and are very reasonably priced. 20 bucks for normal admission or 30 for fast pass. There is no shortage of entertainment while you wait in line, with roaming actors, the lights and music from the DJ, and just good ol people watching. Inside of course is where the fun really begins.

The start of the haunt walks you through some underground caves where you come upon an elevator to make your way into the haunt itself. From then on it's a wild journey through horror after horror. There were some significant changes to the sets from last year, most notably the outside areas. There was an entire village built outside that you walk through. You'll meet zombies, hillbillies, doctors, nurses, witches, graveyard workers,  bayou folk, and not one of them is happy to see you. My favorites were Pyramid Head and the floating fence girl in the Silent Hill scene, and the guy jumping off of the platform toward you then returning back to it way quicker than you'd think possible. Goat man, the weird nurses, and the stitcher were all super memorable as well. The plasma ball didn't work when we went through last year so it was awesome to see that too! Most of the actors there did a fantastic job in their roles. They rely on their roles to scare people rather than just hiding in a dark corner and jumping out at you.

Oh, and keep in mind that the actors are allowed to -and will- touch you as long as you don't have one of the optional new free glow sticks. Glow sticks (henceforth known as wussysticks) are for wusses, so you should avoid them at all costs. You're not a wuss are you? The touch experience made Fear Fair my favorite haunt of the year last year, but this year things seemed to be toned down a bit and I was barely touched at all even though I didn't have a wussystick. From some of the conversations we had with people there, it sounds like the wussysticks have made some of the actors hesitate a little more to touch you because they can't immediately tell if you have the wussystick or not. Some of the costumes are hard to see out of and people aren't usually holding them in the most obvious positions. This is the first year for the wussysticks and while they seem to be drawing more people (wusses) in than prior years, maybe there's a better way to distinguish the wusses from the awesome people who like the full-contact experience for next year. Is there something that's easier for the actors to see so they can determine who can be touched or not? Like a wussy glow necklace? Or a wussy glow diaper? Or a helmet?

There really weren't many places where I could offer suggestions for improvements. I'd say the area I mentioned above with the jumping platform guy could use some fog or a change in lighting to make his approach more dramatic, and the plague village could be broken down into a tighter path with more content. The village itself is awesome, I just think the scare factor could be improved with some more dividers to prevent seeing everything ahead and adding some more specific scenes. It seems like the walk to scare ratio was a bit softer than the rest of the haunt. I also didn't care for moving the merchandise stand into the ticket trailer. When we finished the haunt we all were interested in picking up some kind of souvenirs but we didn't want to wait through the ticket line again to do so.

Oh, and if Pyramid Head could go ahead and take care of all of the wussy people, that would be great too.

Overall, Fear Fair is still one of my favorite haunts I've been to. Quality sets, highly convincing actors, action all over, and scares galore. It's still high on my list of recommendations whenever someone asks me what haunts they should visit, and I'm already excited to see what they bring for next year."

Todd - Fear Fair is a prime example of what immense creativity, high attention to detail and thinking outside the box can accomplish. This was our second year visiting this haunt. For us, it's a two hour drive through no man's land to get to. There's nothing else around and yet we eagerly make this 4 hour round trip JUST to go through. Here's why you should too:

Fear Fair feels as if it refuses to conform. Of course, conformity in the haunt business is an oxymoron in itself, however, much of it is refreshingly original. First off, if you've never been and you follow your GPS (you'll need it), you'll think you've arrived at some sort of outdoor rave. From the street you'll see nothing but a mass of people in front of a second story stage emitting fog and neon lights. You'll hear bass drops and upbeat tempos from modern and classic pop music. You'll think to yourself, "Is this it?" It is.

Both times we've attended Fear Fair, the line was incredibly long. While this is not surprising, the crowd never appears to mind. The music and live entertainment creates a buzz of energy, people are dancing and singing along...it's like a pre-show party. 

On to the haunt. Fear Fair is a touch haunt**. Last year, it was extreme as hell. I vividly recall 3 people at one time trying to pull me down to the ground. It wasn't too aggressive in nature (no getting slammed against walls, etc), but in this case, the zombies were really trying to get me. This year, the touching was toned down drastically in comparison. This in itself doesn't really make the haunt and less appealing; it was just a little disappointing since last year was so memorable because of that. Now - if you think, "Oh, well, it must not be too bad then" - don't get me wrong. There's still enough contact to make the average person uncomfortable. We're used to pretty extreme conditions so for us, it felt a bit more tame than last year. 

**This year Fear Fair has added a no-touch option for the weak-willed. If you insist on not being touched, a glow stick will be provided to you which signals the actors to old back. It's your responsibility to ensure it is displayed at all times.

In my opinion, Fear Fair excels in its environments. The scenes are fantastic, well constructed and very detailed. My personal favorite is without a doubt the Silent Hill area. If you're familiar with the games or movies, you're sure to recognize the ambiance and characters within. It is nailed down to a "T"! Pyramid Head is the star of the area, standing at an impressive 9 feet (?). He wields his iconic long sword and he's not afraid to use it. He grabbed me by the neck again. It was fantastic.

A large addition this year was the Salem-esque county village featuring witches and the falsely accused. Its a large area with small, roofed structures to walk around and through. The plague doctor was very cool (google it if you don't know what the mask looks like). There were a few things about this area to me that left me wanting more. First, the actors. Some were good but others either lacked energy or felt out of place. The witch didn't come across as threatening at all. The falsely accused women did a great job but the true witch was more like ""hahaha I'm the witch and I'll get you""...in a non-Wizard of Oz way. She's the star of this area so there should be some heft to that role. There was also one random villager that was pleading for help in the most effortless way possible. 

The area in general was very cool looking. The new little hut structures are awesome but it felt a little too spaced out in some areas - primarily in the "acrobatic" room where a guy affixed to bungee ropes lunges off a platform , jumping right towards you. It was a very original scare tactic but would have been much cooler if the room was fogged a bit so we couldn't see him as soon as we walked in.

Fear Fair offers many other scenes including a fun Saw-styled area where your group may be split up as well as one of the (if not THE) best cemeteries I've seen. 

This haunt also has some of the most effective jump scares around. The timing and positioning of both actors and props alike were spot on and even got me a few times, which is rare. Many of the walking areas are cramped, leaving you nowhere to run...just the way they like it. 

Overall Fear Fair is well worth your drive, wait and money. It's original, engaging and a LOT of fun. 

Overall Score - 9 / 10
Scare Factor - 9
Actors - 7
Visuals - 10
Value - 10

Teresa - Netherworld in Atlanta has been on my bucket list for quite a few years now. I expected the sets to look professional, but this blew away my expectations. Outside, there were a number of things to see, and people who weren't actively waiting in line were wandering around, taking advantage of the myriad photo opportunities. The lines moved very fast. There were characters (like The Collector who you've seen on the billboards as the ""face"" of Netherworld) working their way through the crowds, scaring people here, posing with them there. They had the largest gift shop I've ever seen at a haunt, full of fun decor and memorabilia. There was also a machine you could use to see people going through Primal Scream and control props to scare them. We bought the Speed Pass, which is about $20 more than the regular tickets. We walked right into both haunts, no waiting. We were told the considerable line would roughly take about 30-40 minutes, which really isn't bad. The first haunt we went in was Primal Scream. I have never been to a haunt like this one. I knew there would be some professional sets and props, but the sets and sheer number of props were staggering. You go through a maze of rooms, each leading into the next. Every inch is decorated. I have never seen this many animatronics in one place. And they were used so well! The noise, sound effects, and music covered any noises the props may have made when operating. And they reset fast! They went off for the first couple of people in our group, then reset and went off again getting the last couple. I think it helps that the area is somewhat confined, so the people in the rear don't see them when they first go off. That's not to say that there aren't some very tall scenes and props. I pointed to some creepy things way over our heads a couple of times. The lighting was very impressive. There weren't a lot of actors, but the costumes were phenomenal and they were like living props. Some even flew overhead! They grabbed for you, but there wasn't any contact. They did a great job with jump scares. The girls in the back of our group were terrified the whole time. There were some unique scenes, like one that made it seem you were on a capsized pirate ship with sea creatures around you. There were falling and collapsing walls. There were several air tunnels, one which inflated while I was in the middle of it. There were a couple of times that we could see another group of people, but we never really caught up to any or had them catch up to us. I find that very impressive with as fast as the line was moving. Primal Scream is a long haunt. I kept expecting to round a corner and see the exit. It just went on forever. I went through the whole thing with mouth agape. This is something you just have to see to believe. It wasn't the scariest one I've been to (although the girls in the back of our group would beg to differ), but visually it is absolutely stunning and so much fun! Like a playground for people who love creepy things!

The second haunt is called Mr. Grendel's Funhouse of Horrors. I figured this would be a pretty standard 3D Clown maze. Again, I was blown away! This is what all the other clown attractions should be! The 3D glasses really made the rooms crazy! The lighting was fun and the effects were awesome. It was like being in a creepy funhouse! And Mr. Grendel and his clown friends are horrifying! I've never seen a better funhouse anywhere. I was disappointed to turn in my glasses, but it wasn't quite over. After we exited, we noticed foam and bubbles floating around everywhere. We were then herded into another section of haunt and told to keep to the right. I went in, thinking I'd be wading through foam, but it was filling the entire space! You couldn't see anything! It was wet and claustrophobic. I finally felt my way through and back out and as my group re-formed, we couldn't stop laughing. We were all covered head to toe in foam. We laughed and snapped a few selfies. This was such a fun and unique experience. It was well worth the money. I just wish I could go through a couple more times. There was just to much to see! By the way, this is their last year at the Norcross location. They will moving to a new location next year. I hope I can make it to Atlanta to check it out!

Paul  - Netherworld is a haunt in the Atlanta, GA area that is widely regarded as one of the scariest haunts in the country. We recently had the opportunity to visit and it was an experience we won't forget.

Our group of three went to the haunt on a Sunday night. We purchased SpeedPasses so we could skip the line, which were a bit on the expensive at $55 each, but not hugely more expensive that most haunts we've been to. We've been to so many haunts where the lines can break 3 hours, we decided the SpeedPass option was probably best.

When we pulled up to the haunt we were waved into a lot where we were charged $10 for parking. This apparently has become a practice that the Netherworld people don't care for but there isn't anything they can do about it. Their on-site free lot is rather small and quickly runs out of space. This is their last year at this particular location and while I didn't ask, I'm thinking the new location will have substantial amounts of free parking.

The property itself is along Interstate 85 on the Northeast side of Atlanta. It's a commercial area full of warehouse-type businesses which all seemed to be closed during the hours of the haunt. There is a searchlight scanning the sky to help you find it. On the walk down the road to the haunt we noticed a bunch of foamy bubbles floating around, which was a little strange, but just figured it was something else to draw people in. Once you get to the property you quickly start to become immersed in the Netherworld experience. There are animatronics everywhere, multiple scenes set up outside for picture opportunities, lots of roaming actors, and it's all minimally lit. There was a pretty substantial line outside so we figured our choice of buying the skip the line passes was probably a good one. We walked around checking everything out and taking pictures, then decided it was time to go in.

There are two attractions at Netherworld: Primal Fear and Mr Grendel's Funhouse of Horrors. We started with Primal Fear.

Primal Fear is absolutely the most intense non-contact haunt I've ever been through. It's the best example of sensory overload that a haunt has given me. The sets are unbelievably detailed, they have non-stop action, perfect lighting, and the audio was on-point. Your senses are assaulted from every direction the whole way through and you really need to go through a few times to be able to take in just how much they've packed into the building. It's completely disorienting and I was immensely impressed with the entire experience. There were quite a few elements I saw that were the big scares at other haunts that Primal Fear had multiples of, and a bunch of unique ones that hadn't seen at other haunts at all. There were things dropping from above, coming up from below, squeezing you in from the sides, and with the way everything was constructed you couldn't see any of it coming while the group in front of you went through.

Mr Grendel's Funhouse of Horrors had me walking in not expecting much. I've been through several clown-themed attractions before, and when we got to the entrance and realized they were passing out 3D glasses I was a little bummed. Every 3D clown thing I've been through has been a let-down- until this one.
This haunt is the gold standard on how a clown haunt should be, especially the 3D aspect of it. There were 3D effects throughout the entire thing, with perfect lighting, huge quantities of content, very unique clown costumes/makeup, and some fantastic special effects. There were a couple of spots where there was some sort of 3D projector running that made it seem like the brick floor was falling away from underneath you, and one of the longest spinning tunnels I've been through. Other haunts doing clown themed attractions should take a trip to Netherworld to see how good one can really be.

When we finished with Mr Grendel's, we discovered where the foamy bubbles we saw when we were walking in were coming from- the foam room. There's a person at the exit of Mr Grendel's who guides you into a room that's FULL of foam. Literally floor to ceiling foam. It's probably only 15 feet long or so, but you can't see anything. I've never gone through anything like that and it was just another piece of the Netherworld puzzle that made it such a fantastic experience. You don't have to go through the foam room but you really should. Just keep in mind you'll be a little wet once you come out.

A few observations I had that really differentiate Netherworld from the Ohio-Kentucky-Indiana region haunts I'm used to:
1. The animatronics  are extremely well-done and they're EVERYWHERE. They have them in almost every scene and the actors work alongside them to make them even better. A lot of haunts will just buy/make an animatronic of some sort and throw it in their building, but these folks fully implement and theme every one of them perfectly into every scene.
2: The actors aren't as critical to the experience. This isn't to say the actors weren't good, but they aren't as integral to the haunt as they are in most. There are tons of them, they give some good scares, and their costumes are excellent, but there really weren't any who had dialogue at all. Pretty much any person could play any part with minimal instruction. I have mixed feelings on this. On one hand, the actors are what make a lot of haunts. If you have a few actors in a haunt who really sell their role, they can make for an extremely memorable experience. On the other hand, if you're counting on that actor to make the experience, that actor usually is really engaging and keeps each group for a few minutes, which slows down the flow of customers. Plus, if for some reason that actor can't get to work one night, it turns a great haunt into a run-of-the-mill attraction. With the number of people they're getting through Netherworld a night, the limited actor interaction is probably the best choice.
3: They pump A LOT of people through this haunt every night. Most haunts have gap of several minutes from group to group, where Netherworld is pushing another group of people through about every minute or so. The most impressive part of it to me was that we still rarely saw any other groups, which also kept us from being able to see the surprises in scenes as they scared the groups in front of us. ZERO spoilers, which was unbelievable for a haunt of this size. We never fully caught up to the group in front of us, and we only saw the group behind us once. I'm VERY impressed that they're able to pull that off as well as they do. That also meant that the huge queue we saw when we got there didn't take 3+ hours at all, it was actually closer to 45 minutes. I'd probably re-think the SpeedPass option for next time unless we were going on a Friday or Saturday night.

If you're in Atlanta or are passing through any time they're open, you need to experience Netherworld. Even though our rating categories don't give it the highest rating we've had, It's a haunt I'll never forget and I'm going to make it a point to try to return again as often as possible. They're moving to their new home in the Stone Mountain area of Atlanta for next year, so maybe that'll give me a good excuse to make it back in 2018!

Overall Score - 8.3 / 10
Individual attraction ratings below

Stillwell Manor
Overall Score - 9.1
Scare Factor - 8.4
Actors - 9.6
Visuals - 9.2
Value - 9.2

Donna - The thing that stands out to me the most about Stillwell Manor  is the overall value. If I could give it a ten I would. This is an entire evening of entertainment!   Three haunts  in one location, firebreather's, roaming actors outside, even food trucks  in case you get the munchies after spending what seems like an eternity inside the haunts. The first haunt we went through was the namesake Stillwell Manor  which is an old haunted house stuck in time 140 years ago. It is very well detailed with residents roaming around who are there to do anything but welcome you to the past.   This is a very very long haunt taking upwards of 45 minutes to go through. 

Gayle - ​This haunt was visually amazing.  So much attention to detail, and had the look and feel of an old, haunted mansion straight out of an old Vincent Price flick.  I thought the engagement was super awesome with the actors, who seemed to follow ME throughout my entire time there.  Great fun, and a nice homage to the classic haunt!!

Paul - Stillwell Manor is a haunt consisting of three attractions: Stillwell Manor, Isabell's Beyond, and Tantibus. All three attractions are included for their very reasonable admission fee, which is $20-$25 for general admission, depending on which night you visit.

When we arrived at the haunt we were greeted with several roaming actors outside including a couple of gentlemen who were blowing fire! The roaming cast had about 6 or 8 characters who made sure you knew you were at a haunt! There were also a couple of food trucks outside cooking up some amazing smelling food to snack on once you worked up an appetite from all of your screaming.

The ticket booth and queue are both right inside the front door and offer one of the better haunt waiting areas. The set and lighting in there make it almost impossible to tell that you're in what used to me a multi-screen movie theater. In fact, that's one of the biggest changes I noticed this year; they hide the 90s-era theater hints better every single year. Last year I remember several scenes where I would look up and see this massive open room that we were in, and it was hard to miss that you were in one of the massive theaters. This year I don't remember seeing that openness once. I think it improved the creepiness of the experience by a pretty good amount.

The first attraction you enter is the original Stillwell Manor. The trip through General Stillwell's home starts in the yard outside, then you wander into and out of his house for one of the best traditional-style haunted houses around. The actors are engaging, the sets are extremely detailed and creepily-lit, and the General's house is BIG. It takes quite a bit of time to make your way through. There are several really memorable areas but my favorites this year were the outdoor/graveyard and the crazy cat lady room. As we wandered through it sure seemed like there were a lot more dark areas and you walked through substantially more swinging doors this year than last. I liked that aspect because it made it harder to see what kind of scene you were walking into until you were pretty much already there. These small things just end up making a better and better experience.

There are only a couple of areas I noticed that could use some improvement. The first is the lighting. Most of the scenes have very appropriate lighting, but there were a couple that I think we missed the full experience of because we couldn't see the set. I don't think they need more room lighting in most cases, mostly just more accent lighting. The other thing is really beyond the control of the haunt, but we definitely noticed they were understaffed on the night we were there. After speaking to the management we found they just had a higher than normal number of them that scheduled off or called in that night. Teenagers...

This really is an excellent haunt. You spend a huge amount of time inside and you really get drawn into the atmosphere of the house. Get yourself over to Stillwell Manor and visit the best haunt in Anderson!

Teresa - ​This was my second time coming to Stillwell Manor. I had such a great time last year I was pretty excited to see it again. As we got close enough, you could see the giant search lights drawing attention to the building. They added some creepy decor including a huge grim reaper and fog to the outside as well as a large tent to provide cover in case of rain. The queue actors were absolutely fantastic. They did a great job of getting jump scares out of people standing around outside (and inside - more on that later). We also met some fire-eating clowns outside. There was food available, so it's a great place to hang out on a nice night. Inside, the ticketing and waiting area make you feel like you're waiting in a haunted castle. Then you enter the Manor of General Stillwell. You start with a pretty cool video, very Haunted Mansion-like, giving you the backstory and rules. Then we were off. This is a nice, long, old-school haunt. There is just so much decor to see. I love just looking around and taking it all in. I noticed it was more enclosed than last year, which adds to the claustrophobic ambiance of a run-down manor. You notice things like the slanted floors in parts of the haunt, which remind you that it is in an old theater, but honestly, I feel like it works. It makes everything seem a little off. I love that. The lighting and sound effects were really good. I especially loved the laser and fog effect that makes you feel like you're wading through a swamp. My only complaint was that we went through all 3 haunts in a large group, of which I was last. I understand a lot of props go off when people enter the room, so being last, I'm going to miss some things, but I expect the actors to interact with everyone and most will even follow and intimidate the person bringing up the rear. For some reason they didn't do that here, and I missed a lot of the scares, which was disappointing. Again, they were very short-staffed and the actors were a lot of subs and volunteers. They could have just been really busy trying to cover the entire haunt. A few of them were really top notch though. I mean, completely over-the-top awesome, which is what I expected after last year. And even the ones I didn't get to see do their spiel may have done a great job and I just missed it. I did love the crazy cat lady and the butcher. Some of the sets are really impressive, too. My favorites are the shack with the creaky floors, the library, the crazy cat lady room, and the graveyard. Also, I get a kick out of going through the closet. There's also a very impressive giant animatronic that I'll just leave as a surprise. The length, decor, and theming make this lots of fun. They offer an add-on to your ticket where you can go through again on the same night. I would consider doing this just to be able to get some food, hang around outside, then go through and see what I missed the first time around. And don't forget, you get two more attractions for your money!

​==I'm going to insert a break here to talk about one particular actor which I'm fairly confident in saying will probably be the most memorable one of the year - Reverend Silas. I couldn't tell you one thing about the real man behind the character because as much time as we spent around him, he never once broke character in the slightest. As for his character, he was amazingly brutal. He's a floating character, meaning he pretty much goes where he wants. You might find him outside with visitors in line and then again somewhere within one of the haunts.

We first encountered him outside when we arrived and he immediately fed on the fears of Gayle who does not hide her scares well at all. Once Silas learned Gayle's name it was game on. He "forced" her to go first in the 2nd and 3rd haunts, crawl on the floor and would threateningly call her name from afar as we went through the haunt. That's amazing dedication!==

Last year we rating Stillwell Manor as the best up and coming haunt. I don't think they are contention anymore because they're "here." Stillwell has proven their potential and pulled off a great experience. I, personally, can't wait to see how it continues to evolve year after year.

As a whole, the entire experience is quite lengthy and carries high value for the price of admission.

Gayle - ​Again, the actors engagement here was above and beyond!  This is where actors can make or break a haunt.  They brought you into the scenes, engaged throughout, entertained, and startled every chance they got.  The haunt itself had some physical aspects that were pretty amazing as well!  Around every turn, there was something cool and someone even more terrifying.  Loved this haunt!

Paul - ​Isabell's Beyond is a carnival freakshow and the freaks want to give you a performance you won't forget. You start out in the entrance tent where the ringmaster goes over how things work and sends you on your way. The attraction takes you up and down stairs, through a maze of tents, and along the way you meet some VERY interesting characters. This was the attraction that seemed hurt the most by the amount of staff missing that night, but we didn't mind so much because one of the roaming actors from outside made his way in and really changed the atmosphere. The Reverend seemed to make it his mission to make sure we got the most out of our visit and he did an excellent job of it!

Teresa - ​When you come out of Stillwell Manor, you have a chance to grab refreshments, or buy a souvenir from what appears to be one of the old concession stands. Then you wait in line for Isabell's Beyond. It is clear from the line decor that this one has a carnival theme. Once you go in, a carnival barker character welcomes you and tells you about Isabell and her band of freaks that you're about to meet. He was outstanding and very entertaining. He started teasing one of our party right off the bat, making her go into a little cubby of shame. 

​And then one of the wandering queue actors, Reverend Silas, made us laugh throughout. I think he really helped out during parts that may have been slow due to the actor shortage. I really think the carnival theme is fun. I like all the red and white striped curtains. The fortune teller was back this year and very entertaining. I also enjoyed some crazy lighting effects. I really missed the seance scene that we got to do last year. I'm not sure if it was cut, or if there just wasn't anyone to work it. This one is shorter on decor and actors compared to the manor, but we still laughed through the whole thing, thanks to some entertaining actors.

Todd - Isabell's Beyond is the second attraction you'll go through. It's themed as a freakshow of sorts. As last year, I still find this to be the weakest link in the Stillwell chain. We were forewarned that they were lean on actors when we visited, but I think there's still opportunity for content. 

Our friend Reverend Silas found us inside to torment Gayle about half way through (this is when she had to start crawling on the floor and barking like a dog). Poor Gayle. Unfortunately, this was the most memorable part of Isabell's Beyond for me. It felt very short and vapid. 

However, I feel there's a HUGE amount of potential here. Out front when we arrived, a few fire eaters were performing. While I understand they can't perform inside, it did spawn the idea what Isabell's Beyond could showcase actual side show artists. The carnival theme is already there (white and red striped panels) but the environment could be enhanced as well. If the level of detail that exists in Stillwell was applied to Isabella's Beyond, I believe the experience would be enhanced tremendously. 

Tantibus
Overall Score - 8.4
Scare Factor - 8.4
Actors - 8
Visuals - 8.8
Value - 8.4

Donna - The last haunt is Tantibus  which means nightmare. This haunt depicts all of your worst nightmares from escaped insane asylum patients to deadly virus spreading mutants to zombies.  You name it it's all here in your nightmares. There's also a fun twist  towards the end but I won't give away the surprise.  I also have to mention the incredible actors throughout the haunt that made it fun and entertaining along with being scary and creepy. Some of the best actors we've seen in any haunt this year! Great job! 
 Last year we rated Stillwell Manor  has the best up-and-coming haunted house. I have to say without a doubt that this year  Stillwell Manor has definitely arrived!  Must see in Indy'!!! 

Gayle - ​What more can I say?  These are a fantastic group of haunts that without a doubt were WELL worth the 2.5 hour trip from Cincinnati.  From the actors engaging people entering the haunt, to the fire breathers outside, to the lighting, sounds, and visual effects...this place was adrenaline overload!!  I was literally jumping every 5 minutes...or maybe I was getting a bit more attention than the rest of my group because I'm an easy target, but it was AMAZING.  Silas definitely made my trip more terrifying in that he seemed to find me no matter where I was!  Great job guys!!  You truly gave me nightmares!  YES!

Paul - ​Tantibus is Latin for Nightmare and this haunt lives up to its name. You go through a bunch of scenes that are straight out of peoples' worst dreams. There's a zombie outbreak, spiders, clowns, and my favorite scene was the girl in the padded room- super creepy! This haunt is pretty detailed and I liked how the nightmares just went from one right into the next. It always seems like my dreams jump randomly from one to the next, so I strangely appreciated how there wasn't much of a transition from one to the next.

Teresa - Tantibus is full of nightmares. We saw everything from clowns to zombies to spiders to deranged doctors. This one definitely ups the scare-factor over Isabell's Beyond. There were some very creepy scenes and I really noticed the sound effects in this one. Also there was a portion where the floor made me uneasy. It looked like it was made of milk crates. And there is a crazy-long, wide slide. It was so long that I started going sideways, which is not what you want when you're sliding into...who knows what! Be sure to secure any personal items that could fall out of your pockets! I really liked the spider scene, the quarantined area, and the doctor at the end. He took one of our group and put her in his chair and was trying to harvest her organs! He did an outstanding job chasing us out with his bone saw. Considering the three attractions, you get a lot for your money here. Our whole group had so much fun. The actors, especially the queue actors, really stepped up to fill the void caused by the regulars being out. I really look forward to seeing them again next year!

Overall Score - 7.1 / 10
Scare Factor - 7.6
Actors - 7.6
Visuals - 6
Value - 7.2

Teresa - This was my first year at Fright Manor. I really enjoyed it! We found out on the way in that this will be their last year at this location. In fact, they were planning to be in a new location and when that fell through, had to set up in this building again in a month's time. I have a feeling the decor was a little rushed because of that, but it was still a lot of fun. This building is large and the haunt is one, long trip, with all kinds of different scenes. We started with a redneck Norman Bates-like character, who was all kinds of talkative. He did a great job of starting us on a humorous note. As we proceeded, there was a mix of humor and horror, sort of alternating throughout. I really enjoyed the interactive nature of some of the scenes, including playing skee ball, playing hide and seek, and the pick-a-door game. Some characters were recognizable from movies (like a scary Freddy Krueger); others were unique. Besides Jeb the redneck, I really liked the gravediggers with the dragging shovels, the guy with the grinder making sparks fly, the clowns who played games with us, and my favorite, the girl with the "pet", who was actually a girl with no tongue. The "pet" followed me down the hall, dragging her chain and she was pretty creepy! Some actors had fun homemade costumes, others had not much makeup at all. What I liked about all of them was their ability to interact and that they would keep following us, popping out at opportune moments. Sometimes I couldn't even see that they were still there, but they would call after me, taunting, long after I thought they were gone. There were some fun props, including the strongest vibrating floor I've ever experienced, and an awesome body strung up horizontally and flailing. We also had to crawl through some portions, and go through some air tunnels, which always makes you feel vulnerable to attack. What this one lacked in decor and polish, I think it made up for with fun actors and sheer length. It has the feel of an old-school haunt. I really like the old traditional haunts when they focus on creativity. I can't wait to see it next year when they have more time to set up in their new location!​

Paul - Fright Manor is kind of an old-school haunt just south of downtown Indianapolis. It's in an old commercial building in an area where I wouldn't ordinarily expect a haunted attraction to be, but they do a pretty good job with the space, especially given the limited setup time this year due to some unforeseen location problems.

Due to the location issues there were a few obvious shortcomings. One month of setup time isn't nearly enough for a haunt of this size. They use up just about every possible inch of the building, which makes it a pretty long voyage, but there's a pretty heavy amount of un-themed plywood walls that line your path. The lighting is fairly sparse and there are a few areas that could have used some music or noise of some sort; one of the ones that sticks out in my mind is the outside maze portion at the end. It was so quiet in there I was beginning to think we had wandered into an unfinished part of the haunt that we weren't supposed to be in. Like I said, I understand, I just have to mention this stuff as part of the review.

BUT... even with the areas that could use improvement, this haunt was a blast! There are a few scenes I don't remember seeing anything remotely similar to in other haunts, and even being several days out from visiting Fright Manor, I vividly remember more of the experiences here than I do at most haunts I visit. The glowing mask room is a fantastic idea, the blacked-out room with the gravedigger(s?), the clown skee-ball, and the hillbilly house all stand out, as do a few characters; Hillbilly PBR-drinking White Castle-eating guy, Freddy, the clowns, the gravediggers, grinder guy, and the "pet" on the leash. Some of the animatronic props were super old-school, which actually made them more fun than some of the new stuff you see out there.

I had a good time at Fright Manor. Even though the visual appeal may not have matched some of the bigger haunts out there, it's still a really good time. As much fun as I had here with their shortened setup, I can't wait to come back once they have the full production at their new location next year!

Donna - Fright manor is always one of the highlights of our Indy Road trip!  Tom  has been putting on a great show since 1983 and, even though it has changed locations a few times  over the years,  it continues to be one of the best in the Indianapolis area. This year was one of the better years for this haunt in my opinion as it had an old school feel and a tremendous amount of detail and every room. Even though they didn't have a lot of time to build this year, you would never know it to go through the haunt witch is by the way very very long.  
 The actors are very good especially the first room which is more comical than scary but It got us laughing right away. As you progress through the haunt each room has a different theme and  some are comical where some are terrifying  but all are entertaining and fun. This haunt is well worth the money and I would highly recommend it as an annual Halloween tradition. 

Gayle - ​I really enjoyed this haunt!  It had the look and feel of a classic haunt.  These are the types that lured me in as a kid!  I felt the scenes and props were well done, and there were several eerie areas, where it was somewhat quiet, but not for long.  The actors were well placed and did a great job with startling people as they walked through.  I do know this haunt was put together in an unusually short amount of time, which speaks volumes toward the passion and dedication of the owner and his staff!!  There was talk of this haunt moving back to their original location, which was before I had visited Fright Manor, but after having several discussions about it, I'm SUPER excited to visit next year.  I had a great time, enjoyed it thoroughly, and look forward to seeing you guys next year!  Excellent job!!!   

Todd - Fright Manor is a haunt with history spanning three decades in numerous locations. For me, walking through Fright Manor felt like half haunt, half haunt museum. It's actually a little fascinating and very nostalgic. What I enjoyed the most was the amazing collection of props from years past. Looking at some of the items, monsters, etc., scene to scene, it's clear that some of them have been in use or in rotation for quite some time. I don't mean to insinuate that they're dilapidated; they're actually quite unique and not at all commonly found among other haunts with less tenure. This is where Fright Manor makes an impression on me - I feel like I'm witnessing a little haunt history. 

I'd say that Fright Manor is a conventional haunt because it really is just an old-style haunt that doesn't burden itself with having to maintain a theme or an over-arching story. As you go through, you'll simply encounter various nightmarish scenes - clowns, graveyards, gory rooms, dolls, psychopaths, etc. Each scene stands apart from the others, some with highly memorable characters too. 

There is also some level of interaction as well in a few areas. Some produce scares targeting one lucky member of your party while others involve some rather entertaining story telling. It might be a good idea to stretch ahead of time too. You'll need to get on your hands and knees and crawl through short tunnels in a few areas (there's a cheat path if you absolutely can't).

There were a few area where it was a little unclear which way to go whether it was due to the sheer darkness of the area or the indeterminable difference between the curtain leading to the next scene and the one intended for the actors. There were also a few scenes where it was very quiet. Next to lighting, sound is the best accompaniment to a scene and it can surely help draw visitors into the ambiance. While the sound of other scenes didn't necessarily carry through the building, the dead quiet in some areas is very apparent.

One surprising factor is the length. From the outside, Fright Manor's current residence doesn't not look like a whole lot of anything, nor does it give any hint of how long it is. There are signs of course, but the building is very unassuming. The maze within is laid out very efficiently, winding all the way down from one end to the other, then back.  

The haunt itself is run by a great group of friendly people. It's has a very welcoming atmosphere and is a great haunt for families with older (or brave) kids. I'm highly anxious to return next year as we have learned Fright Manor is likely to move to its previous location. While I've never been there, it sounds like it was a much more optimal location. I'm excited to see how the space is utilized. 

Overall Score - 9.5 / 10
Scare Factor - 9.5
Actors - 9.5
Visuals - 10
Value - 9

Gayle - I have to say, USS Nightmare has always been a favorite of mine, because it has always been different.  This year, they've set themselves apart even more!  They have made some FANTASTIC changes in terms of offering new levels of experiences.  They've changed some rooms, added many new props, changed some themes, and tell an even more engaging story than ever before.  The actors are simply incredible...special props to the makeup artists!  The story-line and level of interaction are like no other haunt in this area.  Each passenger is taken on a grisly tour of an old, haunted ship, and along the way they are being engaged, and interacting along, with the actors in this journey.  The RIP Experience is PHENOMENAL.  You are given tasks, edibles, and could be pulled away from your group to be locked in a cell until they've found your key....just sayin'!  The fog room is visually incredible, and the decontamination room is disorienting and mind-blowing!  LOVED every intense, creepy, and entertaining second of it.  What a GREAT time!!!  

Donna - ​ We have been going to the USS nightmare for many years and essentially the theme is always the same a haunted boat with the captain appearing somewhere on board to scare you.   This year we were in for a big surprise. We did the RIP tour which I highly recommend you will not be sorry! This is a very intense hands-on interactive walk-through that will have you  screaming for the exit holding your breath and thoroughly entertained throughout your terrifying trip. The actors are top-notch the best I've seen this year.   There are new parts of the boat to be discovered the storyline is well thought out and well acted by everyone involved.  It is dark where it should be dark and creepy and funny at times but I guarantee you this will be the height of your Halloween season. Well done Haunt!  If you have not been to USS Nightmare please go!    This haunt gets an A+ from the Fightmaster. 

Paul - USS Nightmare takes place on an actual river dredge boat that's floating on the Ohio River in Newport, KY,  right across from downtown Cincinnati. This is a huge ship built by the Army Corps of Engineers to remove earth from under the water on the Ohio and Mississippi rivers. It was retired some years ago and now is a VERY good haunt.

The original dredging equipment is still on she boat. As you wait in line you're right next to the giant reels of cable that fed out to the dredge device, and as you go through the haunt you're constantly walking around original machinery and componentry that supported the work that this piece of history performed. The authenticity of all of this adds so much to the feel as you journey through. I really want to go through and see the ship sometime when the haunt isn't happening, just so I can see the equipment and the history!

The story says the ship was a really intense place to work and the captain was a bit of a slave-driver. He ran a large crew up and down the river and because he was a widower, his daughter Anna lived on board as well. Because it was such a rough life on board the vessel, the captain would occasionally let entertainment aboard when he would stop for food and supplies. This entertainment was often a group of clowns from whatever carnival was nearby to the refueling stop. (Knowing this beforehand would have made a lot more sense of the clown scenes.) There were many deaths on board over the years and toward the end of the boat's active life, it somehow broke free from its mooring one day and started floating downstream and smashing into things along the way. The captain was killed during this disaster, and Anna was never found.

Early on you end up in an elevator where they kind of explain the origins of what's happening on the ship. The elevator operator was really entertaining and did a great job with his part. New this year is the RIP Experience which allows the actors to touch you and adds extra scenes and rooms to the haunt. It isn't like they grab you and throw you around, but they definitely take advantage of being allowed to touch you and do quite a bit of invading your personal space. The elevator guy was our first intro to this and it really adds to the haunt. Well worth the upgrade to do the RIP!

There are so many notable scenes in this haunt it's hard to mention them all, but if you think about the types of rooms you'd find on a working ship, you'll find them here. Boiler/mechanical room, kitchen/galley, really nasty bathroom, Captain's quarters, crazy clown area, fog room, workshop, etc. (All ships have crazy clown and fog rooms right?) The sets were all extremely well-done and the actors were fantastic! This haunt is long, scary, detailed, and several of the actors were among the best I've seen in a haunt; improvisation, costumes, and makeup were excellent.

The only thing I noticed as somewhere they could improve upon is better presentation of the back story of the haunt. I had no idea why there were clowns on the boat until I went to the website afterwards and read the stories. Maybe add a couple of weatherproof TVs outside in the area where you wait in line that could play the videos from the website? There may have been some explanation in the elevator at the beginning but the actor in there was kind of hard to ignore. It's a minor thing, but it would have explained a couple of things that didn't seem to fit the theme.

Overall, I highly recommend the USS Nightmare! It's a great haunt in a perfect location. It's long -I think around 40 minutes for our group-, it has fantastic theming, talented actors, and isn't very expensive. Take a ride down to the river and get on board! 

Overall Score - 10 / 10!
Scare Factor - 10
Actors - 10
Visuals - 10
Value - 10

Teresa - If you are an adrenaline-junkie, this is the haunt for you! This is a full-contact haunt that takes place in a madman's hotel, full of depraved characters. It is aggressive, vulgar, and intense, and not suitable for children. If you have any doubt about whether you can handle it, just hang out outside for a few. The costumes on the wandering queue actors are terrifying! There was this creepy girl there the night we were there, with long dark hair, like something that crawled out of The Ring, with this goo coming out of her mouth. She didn't move like a human. She had people who were trying to buy tickets running down the street screaming and hiding behind their umbrellas. Too bad that was close to where the chainsaw guy was chasing people out of the haunt. When you do work up the courage to go inside, you meet the owner/caretaker. This guy is fantastic. He grabs you by the head and forces you to line up against the wall while he tells you about his hotel. While he was talking, this other character I can't begin to describe was being so creepy it was mesmerizing. Then we entered the elevator. I've seen people lose it at this point. This place is gorey, gross, and disturbing. We were grabbed, shocked, dragged, shoved against walls and onto tables, picked up, thrown onto beds, had our heads shoved into toilets, had gross items shoved in our faces. It was so much fun!!! The actors are very intense and the makeup is really good. There was a very memorable scene with a narrator, reading from a book, and narrating our movement across this creepy grate in the floor that looked like it could collapse. It reminded me of In The Mouth of Madness. He had us laughing as we went up the stairs. I'm always sad when we exit the building, as it is always over too soon, but I was happy that they added what felt like quite a bit to the outdoor section this year. Because of the heavy rain, some of the lights were out in this section and a character had to shine a flashlight on part of it for us. It may have been even creepier this way. You walk through the maze, just waiting for the chainsaw guys to find you. And wow, are they intimidating, with sparks flying! I love the theme, the run-down hotel decor, the freakishly scary actors, and I love that they were able to up the intensity from last year. Did I get a couple bumps and scrapes? Maybe. Is it totally worth it? YES!!! And in the car on the way home, I saw blood on my arm. Not mine. Stage blood. Probably. And somehow that was like a souvenir. General admission is $25 and worth every penny if you really want to be scared. There are coupons available on the website for Thursdays and Sundays. Oh, and there's a special lights-out night. I really want to come back for that!

Paul - WOW!

The Haunted Hotel is an intense, dark, crazy, nasty, nightmare of a haunt, and I loved every second of it! This is a full-contact haunt and they're definitely not afraid to make some contact. We were picked up, thrown around, yelled at, made fun of, and don't even think that you have any personal space here. The sets, makeup, costumes, music, lights, and special-effects were all outstanding, but the actors are what made it. Their interaction with you as you go through is some of the best I've experienced, whether they were scaring you, shoving you around, making you laugh, or just standing there looking about as creepy as could be. Whether you're Inside or outside of the haunt, you're going to run into some of the scariest actors around. They don't do anything that physically harms you, but you'll remember this place for years to come!"

Todd - The Haunted Hotel is back on point!

Over the past 5 years, the Haunted Hotel proved to be a relentless experience of full contact scares, extreme violation of personal space and one hell of a fun time.

Last year, we felt a little let down and if you read our review, it was pretty evident. Maybe it was just the masochists in us disappointed with the reserved level of hands-on contact. Would we let that stop us from coming back this year? Hell no! The Haunted Hotel means more to me than Christmas with the family. I wouldn't miss it for the world - and - I'm happy to report that the stars have realigned and this year was fantastic!

If you're unfamiliar with this haunt, it's important to note that it's a bit unconventional. Yes it's a house and yeah, it's dark and there are things that make you jump. However, the real heart and soul of The Haunted Hotel are the actors. These aren't the kind of actors that hide around a corner and pop out shouting "Boo." No, these actors are more like professional violators. You WILL be touched...but not just touched...more like grabbed....and shoved...maybe licked, sniffed or uncomfortably caressed. 

A few actors have more standout performances such as the hotel owner who is quite up front about your fate upon entry. The mood is perfectly set with his opening monologue and I've personally seen a number of people never make it past this first room. Other actors are simply there to be brutal. I was thrown against 2 walls, bent backwards over a railing with a dull knife to my throat, thrown down on to a ragged couch, and went forehead to forehead with many others. In short - they're not shy. Will you get injured...no. Will you perhaps get some mild bruising? Possibly. I'm confident that the actors know how to read people and are aware of each visitors personal limits. 

A few rooms have been modified this year and the outside section at the end has been expanded with a sewer scene that was pretty cool, along with what felt like even more walls creating a longer maze for the chainsaw-wielding maniacs. 

The Haunted Hotel may not be the most themed haunt, the most aesthetically decorated, but it excels at what it is intended to be which is an experience at a whole other level. For good or for bad, I never find myself having "down time" going through the haunt to take in all of the scenes because I'm too distracted by whoever is grabbing me or throwing me around at that moment. It's dark, dingy, gritty and relentless. It's an entirely different experience than most haunts have to offer and it "makes you feel alive" which to me, is what makes is so damn good.

Overall Score - 7.6

Fort Harmony's Revenge
Overall Score - 7.6
Scare Factor - 6.7
Actors - 7.3
Visuals - 8
Value - 8

Teresa - Fort Harmony's Revenge is the more established of the two haunts. I really enjoyed the changes they made to this one for this year. Now, you wait in what looks like a street in front of an old theater. On going inside, before going into the haunt, you can get group photos in front of your choice of backdrop. Then you are seated in a theater. While we were waiting for the movie to start, a character entertained us with jokes and songs. The movie was a 1950s-style movie, giving us background information about the town of Fort Harmony. It was well-done and there were some disturbing images of eyeballs. Then there was another short wait next to old movie posters, Godzilla, and a giant man-eating spider (or maybe it was a tick?) and we were inside the town of Fort Harmony. They did a really good job creating this town that seemed to take us back to the 1950s. The actors were a mix of creepy and entertaining (and unpredictable!). There were lots of jump scares. The sets were detailed with lot of interesting props that helped take you way back to mid-last century. I feel like there was so much to take in that I really need to go through a second time to see what I missed the first time around. Each character and room or shop is giving you a little piece of the story. And there's a lot going on here. Definitely some witchcraft and lots of insanity! I won't spoil the end, you'll just have to check it out! Aside from the other haunt in the building, which I'll talk about separately, they have some refreshments and Halloween items for sale. There's also a coffin-ride, and an upgrade where you get strapped to a wheelchair and pushed through the haunt alone. Someone please do this and tell us what you think! And there are lots of special events throughout the year. There are family events (like lights-on trick-or-treating), and extreme upgrades where the actors will touch you and scare the living daylights out of you. I so want to do this! While we were there, there was a Haunters Against Hate event going on, complete with drag show with tips going to benefit the Louisville Youth Group. Which brings me to the outside portion, which has grown a ton and turned into a circus. There are booths with food, games, fortune telling, and a stage for karaoke (or in our case, a drag show). There was a decent turnout, considering it was pouring rain that night. And never to be forgotten, Chaos the clown was back this year. Do go see him!

Paul - In Fort Harmony's revenge, you go through a town that Witches cursed and made the town eternally night. This caused everyone to go crazy and you have to get out. The intro movie was very good, the lead-in actors were great, and the progression through the town was well-executed. It was fairly long, themed well, had pretty good makeup and costumes, but the actors kind of let me down in this one. They weren't bad, but they seemed to just hang out in dark corners and jump out while making loud noises when you went into rooms. It got to be a little repetitive. I had a couple of occasions where they surprised me but I like seeing actors in a creepy starting position too, not having them jump out from a hiding place all of the time.

Todd - The 7th Street Haunt has gone through some revisions and expansions since last year. An outdoor circus/carnival tent with games and entertainment has been added out front. Once inside, visitors are first directed to the original haunt, Fort Harmony's Revenge and then are immediately queued into Unit 732, a new haunt added to the roster this year. 

Fort Harmony's Revenge has gone though some changes since last year. Aside from alterations within the haunt, the entire flow of the experience has changed into a very Disney-esque experience. Visitors will first have their picture taken with a variety of backgrounds to choose from. Next up is a small movie theater complete with actual theater seats in which a short intro movie is played introducing both haunts. The film is quite well done. The introduction for Fort Harmony's revenge sets up the lore in an early 60's B-horror movie fashion, while Unit 732 is introduced in more of a late 70s grindhouse style (The haunt itself even takes place in the 80s). After the movie, you're fed right into the queue for Fort Harmony's Revenge.

The haunt itself has been changed somewhat, but mostly resembles the same "town" we visited last year. The town staples are still there - the butcher shop, the florist, the caves, etc. One of the most memorable scenes last year for me was the Reba McEntire room which was a true "WTF" moment for me. Sadly, it looks to have been converted to the Marilyn Monroe room....I think. There's a lot crammed into the space allocated for the haunt, which while it leaves many varying scenes to experience, makes me wonder if less, but bigger and even more detailed scenes would be better. Some of the rooms are so small that you're already through them before you can really take everything in.

For the most part, the actors were decent. Some really nailed their character while others seem to go with more generic material that didn't pertain to their scene one way or another. A few missed the mark, especially one in particular who was a bit of a soft talker and pretty hard to understand. Her dialogue was very relevant to the story and experience so that casting felt like a big miss. 

Overall FHR feels more like an old school haunt. It doesn't have a lot of flashy tech and is heavily reliant on atmosphere to carry the mood. It has a very strong story which is carried fairly well throughout but I think there's opportunity to play more into that story in the scenes that feel more ambiguous. I feel this haunt could be improved with more interactivity as well since the story is so strong. 


Unit 732
Overall Score - 7.7
Scare Factor - 7.3
Actors - 7.3
Visuals - 8
Value - 8

Teresa - This one was entirely new for 2017. They chose the name Unit 732 from a contest to name the haunt. After doing some research, it evidently comes from a super-secret unit doing biological and chemical warfare experiments back in World War II. I love this idea! When you first go in, you are in a waiting room, which looks like it may be from the 1980s. The receptionist asked us about our favorite music and sang us a song from that era. From there we visited various doctors, some of whom were performing some pretty disturbing experiments, some patients in need of rescue, and others that were completely crazed lunatics. They warn you not to touch anything or you will become infected. We would so be members of the maniac club ourselves, as the first character who came along and asked us to touch something gross-looking, we all did it. What can I say? We like to participate! Unit 732 was more sparsely decorated than Fort Harmony, but it worked with the theme. I really enjoyed the tilted floor leading into the rotating tunnel. All-in-all the theme of this one reminds me a lot of Zombie City in Asylum Haunted Scream Park. I look forward to seeing if it develops over the years in the same way. I really like that theatrical, interactive style of haunt with a story to follow, so I hope this one does that. You get admission to both of these haunts for a very reasonable $28 dollars. I definitely give it a recommend. There are coupons available on the website too. The carnival and live entertainment outside make it a great place to hang out for the evening. And don't forget to check out the special events!

Paul -In unit 732, people were infected by a virus that made them nuts. Most of them seemed very hungry and not happy to see us, and definitely made that known! The actors were a lot more fun in this one and did a much better job of not just jumping out from shadows as you walked in. They were much more interactive and did an excellent job of upping the scare factor with their characters. Again the sets, costumes, and lighting were very professional, and you really felt like you were in some pretty crazy places while going through. This was definitely my favorite at 7th street!

Todd - As a child of the 80s (yeah, I'm old.......or perhaps young, to you), I got a real kick out of the dated nostalgia in Unit 732. Right from the get-go we were greeted by the facility's secretary sporting big poofy hair, complete with a big pink ribbon. She also informed us that Quiet Riot's "Mental Health" has just been released. That was a great way to set the era, although I wonder if today's teens would even get that.

Those who have also visited Asylum Haunted Screampark will notice a fun tie-in between Unit 732 and Asylum's Zombie City - both are themed around Paragon, a fictitious research group responsible for turning the town (and this ward) into a hoard of zombies. 

Unit 732 is a more modern-styled haunt (presentation wise) than Fort Harmony's Revenge. The lighting was a little more dynamic and more mainstream effects of "today" were used.That's not to say that the actors aren't contributing. Along with the expected infected doctors / researchers, you'll also come across other 80s-styled characters. I personally enjoyed the street punks wearing leather jackets complete with metal rivets who look like they're straight out of "The Warriors." 

The style of the haunt compared to Zombie City was more traditional; there was no interactivity of the story line. Most of the haunt was driven by gory scenes, scare jumps (mostly loud bangs produced by the actors) and actors getting up close and personal. While it was fun to go through, there wasn't anything that really stood out greatly to me. It's not a bad haunt but the theme and execution felt status quo to others haunts storied around zombies or outbreaks. The 80s era added a bit of uniqueness to it, however, I found that more memorable than the haunt itself.

Overall Score - 10 / 10!
Scare Factor - 10
Actors - 10
Visuals - 10
Value - 10

Teresa - This is one scary place! They put on a fun show outside for those waiting, with good music, and wandering actors, like Orlock and the Scarecrow. Orlock is really fun to talk to! And we missed it this year, but look for the Devil himself to make an appearance every so often. They also do group photos which make for good souvenirs. Once you get inside, it is impossible not to be impressed. Horror fans will be in...well, hell! It certainly isn't heaven! These are professional-quality movie sets, re-created so you can visit all your favorite horror movies and characters! The actors' costumes and makeup are phenomenal. And the actors were fully immersed in their characters and very intimidating! It is probably the scariest non-contact haunt I've been to this year. These actors seriously violate your personal space. You get to experience 13 Ghosts, Evil Dead 2, The Texas Chainsaw Massacre, Sleepy Hollow, The Mummy, Hellraiser, and The Exorcist, to name a few. They are somewhat limited in space in their building and it is always over too soon, but the price is very good for what you get. The Speedpass is a great deal if they are busy when you are there. And this one isn't too far from some of the other Louisville haunts if you want to make a longer night of it. If you really want a scary haunt, and you are a horror movie fan, I can't recommend this one enough. And if it isn't scary enough, they have a full-contact experience called CHAOS that I'm dying to go to. Two nights only! Check it out and let us know what you think!

Paul - The Devil's Attic is one of the best haunts I've ever been through! You walk in and each scene is a scene from a horror/thriller movie of some kind. There were scenes from Frankenstein, Saw, The Exorcist, Hellraiser, and tons of others. Every set had amazing detail, they had some of the best-used animatronics I've seen, the actors did phenomenal jobs, and the costumes and makeup were perfect! The scare-factor was outstanding, and it kept up through the entire thing. It's only $20 to get in and it's one of the best haunt bargains around. Highly recommended!!

Todd - Most memorable for its recreation of horror's most famous film icons and scenes, The Devi's Attic has hit a trifecta of near-perfection this year. The scenes look incredible, the actors are highly energetic and in character and despite each scene's physical space being somewhat limited, the scare tactics used are executed brilliantly. Upon entering a scene you may think you see the actors involved and then out of "nowhere" comes the real scare. The art of diversion and distraction has been mastered.

Many of the scenes from previous years remain. Every year I rave about the Hellraiser scene and for damn good reason - it's amazing. What I love the most, besides how great it looks, is that it starts with Frank (the post puzzle box, mostly re-constructed Frank). Everyone can recognize Pinhead (film fans will surely recognize Chatterer and Butterball as well) but only the true die-hard fans will instantly recognize Frank - the man unsatisfied by all earthly pleasures. 

With the continuing positive reception to the Ash Vs. Evil Dead TV show, fans will be happy to find that the Evil Dead 2 scene remains and he who plays Ash does a crazy good job. 

Of course, let's not forget the big man himself either, "The Devil", who always looks excellent delivering his iconic monologue as you begin the tour. After all, it's his collection.

I was happy to find a few new scenes - most notably, Bloody Mary and The Mummy (which had some amazing costuming). 

Whether your a horror fan, a haunted house fan or especially both, you'll appreciate on-going excellence The Devil's Attic offers in both scares and authenticity of horror legends it pays homage to. 

This was easily the best we've seen The Devi's Attic and the perfect score is well deserved!

Overall Score - 7.5 / 10
Individual attraction ratings below

Zombie Hunting
Overall Score - 5.2
Scare Factor - 4
Actors - 5.3
Visuals - 5.3
Value - 6

Teresa - The paintball is much better than the last time I did it. There were more zombies to shoot at, and they put on a pretty good show, coming right up to the windows of our vehicle. The driver was entertaining as well. You have the option to buy more paintballs if you really want to go crazy. The course is still pretty short. You actually end up going back and forth over the same area several times. That didn't bother me too much though. It's the live (undead?) zombies that you can shoot that matter more than the scenery. Personally, I wouldn't pay for this alone, but as part of the All Access Pass, it is a fun bonus. How often do you get the chance to shoot zombies that aren't on a video screen?

Paul - I hate rating Zombie Hunting as low as I am, but it just doesn't fit our categories well. I enjoyed it quite a bit more than the ratings reflect.

Zombie Hunting is an attraction where you get to shoot paintballs at zombies. You board an old school bus with paintball guns mounted in the window openings and they drive you around a course while you shoot zombies who jump out from hiding places. As zombie paintball attractions go it's pretty fun. You get a decent supply of paintballs and the guns seem pretty accurate. It would have been nice if the course was a little longer and had more than the 2 or 3 zombies I saw, but I still had fun with it and was startled by a sneaky zombie or two who snuck really close to the bus and surprised us all.

Todd - Zombie Hunting is a paintball course in which a converted bus with mounted paintball guns drives in a field which is surrounded by building facades with both live actors as well as body props. Various cars and other scenery are sprinkled throughout in the event you're really trigger happy. 

I was pleasantly surprised to find improvements over last year. First, last year I do not recall any live actors. Not only are there a few, but they add a little bit of entertainment by walking up to the bus, banging on it, etc. The driver even added some flavor dialogue to help the experience. 

Each rider begins with 150 paintballs which can get you through the ride at a moderate shooting pace. Extras can be purchased for those who need to really let out some aggression. 

This particular attraction would be better (in my opinion) if it ran through the woods or a more linear path rather than circling a field, but I also recognize converting it to such a setup could be a daunting task requiring more land. 

Xterminate Mutant Attack
Overall Score - 7.3
Scare Factor - 8
Actors - 8
Visuals - 5.3
Value - 8

Teresa - In this attraction, there has been an incident that causes all of these clowns to turn into mutant clowns who want to kill you. Your mission is to find these 3 hidden objects so you can cure the mutant clowns and save the world. In my opinion this one was much improved over last year. The guns automatically reload and having a mission made it a much more engaging experience. I really found this to be lots of fun. It feels like living a video game. The sets are pretty basic, but well-done. It is hard enough to find your way through, look for the hidden boxes, and shoot clowns all at the same time, so you wouldn't appreciate elaborate decorations anyway. We moved through the maze of rooms and buildings, looking for the hidden boxes, and all the while, clowns were jumping out and chasing us. You really have to be quick on the draw. I thought it was very exciting! Sadly, we only ended up finding 2 of the 3 boxes, sorry about your luck, world. For me, this is a unique experience I haven't had at other haunted attractions, so it's a no-brainer to at least get the Scare Pass which includes this, Zombie City, and Darkness Falls, if not the All Access Pass where you can do all 4 attractions for the price of 2 purchased separately.

Paul - Here we have a building infested with mutated clowns who are out to get you while you run through a huge area trying to find the switches to the system that will cure them. It's a huge maze that you run through with a laser tag gun to protect yourself. When you shoot a clown they have sensors that make lights on them start flashing, which stuns them for 3-5 seconds so you have some time to get away. This was actually the attraction I had the most fun in. Running around through the maze looking for the switches with clowns jumping out at you and hiding in corners was a blast! Definitely a few startling moments when clowns would jump out from unexpected places too.
I had to leave the visual score low just because you were running through basic wooden building structures. It was still completely enjoyable, but rating this high wouldn't give due credit to the other attractions.

Todd - It's laser tag - Rambo style! First - I'll say it again. BEST laser tag-style guns ever. Love them! No breakdowns this year either!

Xterminate was MUCH improved this year. In previous years, people just ran around randomly shooting at any zombie actor they could find in the allotted time. There was no scoring or any objective other than maybe burning a few calories. 

This year, the theme has been switched to mutant clowns (after all, it's the year of the clown with IT being out) and you're tasked with finding 3 large panels with switches which will release the cure, all before time runs out. This worked so much better for this attraction. The course is a very large indoor area with room structures inside with a lot of doorways to weave through and many windows to keep an eye on.

I found it to be so much more enjoyable actually having to find things while still shooting the clowns (which of course only temporarily stuns them) and keeping them out of my way. Conveniently for them, when you did find a switch, it makes a loud cracking noise alerting them to your location. The actors were pretty high-energy and had no reservations about waiting for you in a dark corner. 

We only found 2 of the 3 boxes before the time was up. Xterminate this year was by far the most fun of either previous visit.

Zombie City
Overall Score - 8.5
Scare Factor - 7.3
Actors - 9.3
Visuals - 8.7
Value - 8.7

Teresa - Zombie City is an on-going story that has been evolving every year. It is an interactive experience, where you and the people in your group are led through a zombie-infested city and you have to try to get through it alive. You meet up with various characters, some of whom are there to help, some are zombies, and some are infected, crazed lunatics. And disturbingly, it isn't always easy to tell the difference. The sets, actors, and story are great. The characters force you to participate and make decisions and look for objects you'll need to get through alive. This is a lot of fun. Unfortunately, we had a couple people in our group this year who didn't want to participate, who tried their best to ruin it for the rest of the group by making dumb comments and lagging behind and trying to show how not-scared they were. I only mention this because our guide, Gwen, did a commendable job of dealing with them. The actors really are fantastic. This is another unique experience, because rarely do you get to interact with the characters to the extent you do in this very theatrical production. Highly recommended! The only thing that would make it better is real zombies to pick off the people who shouldn't survive!

Paul - This was the most interactive of the haunts, which made it different from any other haunt attraction I've been through. It was almost like being in a live-action video game. You enter into a research facility owned by Paragon Technologies where an outbreak has caused chaos and you have to escape and make your way to safety with the help of a guide. I really enjoyed how this one progressed and how the guide kept the scenes moving. The people that were paired with our group were very challenging, and though I could tell Gwen was frustrated with them, she kept things on track remarkably well. There were several really creepy scenes, awesome sets, some good scares, enthusiastic acting, and it was a really memorable attraction. Great time! 

Todd - Once again Zombie City pulls you into an experience, not just a haunt. Rather than a conventional path or maze you walk through yourself, Zombie City always had a primary actor who leads you down the path, feeding into the story, which changes and evolves each year. The over-arching story revolves around Paragon, a research firm who has inadvertently caused a zombie outbreak that has affected the whole area. 

This year our guide was found immediately trapped in a room. Upon letting her out, she informed us she knew the way through town. As she led us through the town, we encountered many residents including a delirious bus driver, cannibals, religious cultists and an incredibly well-acted doctor who was featured on the intro video that sets up the story. This guy was fantastic, by the way!

Along the way various threats present themselves and there's interaction between the characters and your guide that contribute to the story. Sometimes you may need to look for something, carry something from one scene to another, etc. There are some interesting effects that take place as well which assist in pulling you into the experience - I won't spoil them here, though.

Zombie City isn't necessarily the scariest attraction at Asylum but it's a very unique take on a haunt that we haven't really found anywhere else. It brings interactivity to a whole other level and presents something different and refreshing.

Darkness Falls
Overall Score - 9
Scare Factor - 8
Actors - 9.3
Visuals - 9.3
Value - 9.3

Teresa - Darkness Falls is a long trail you walk through some creepy woods. There are some really memorable scenes, including these glowing white mannequins, a shanty town full of crazed cannibals, one actor who was cutting the skin off of someone, a couple cults, a chef offering up yummy meal worms, some insane clowns, a great cemetery and crypt, slides, a couple spots where your group is split up, and a surprise from above. And, of course...chainsaws. This is a great, long, classic trail haunt. The actors were really entertaining and scary, and the scenes are professional quality with very good use of props. This is well worth the cost of admission. I'd highly recommend the Scare Pass or All Access Pass to take advantage of the price breaks. Plus all of the attractions are really fun and quite different, so why not make an evening of it? The park also has food available, a stage show with fire-eaters and other carnival-type acts, a booth with jewelry, and group photos. There was one wandering actor who was really cracking me up. He looked like a creepy rabbit or like a character from the movie, You're Next. He did an awesome job of stalking people, and just popping up in the most unexpected places. He was really freaking some people out. Kudos to him!

Paul - This is a haunted trail through the woods. It's a really long haunt with some very memorable scenes and actors. Some major creepiness to this one, and some awesome scares. I'd say the weirdest scene for me was the one with all of the mannequins. So eerie! This is the longest haunt at Asylum, and I'd say the signature one. There are a few things here that really stood out, but I don't want to spoil them for anyone who hasn't been. I'll just say that some of the scares came at you from unexpected places! This is one of the best haunted trail type attractions I've been through.

Asylum also did a really good job of spacing out groups too. We didn't see any other groups in any of the haunts the whole time we were there. That's a really important factor to drawing people into a haunt for a really good scare, and I'd say is under-appreciated by most people. The lines can be a little longer because of it, but it's well worth it!

Todd - Darkness Falls is, in my opinion, the premier attraction at Asylum. It's a very long, dark, outdoor trail overflowing with various themes and structures. It has everything from crazy hillbilly cannibals, to clowns, to psychopathic murderers, to cultists...it's got it all!

The actors were great. They all played their role quite well within their theme, never breaking character. I'll give a few shout outs - First to the gentleman performing the intro monologue. He did a great job setting the tone. Secondly, one guy about half way in the woods actually stopped us for a moment because we were catching up with the group in front of us. He maintained his demeanor but did explain he wanted to ensure we had the best possible experience by avoiding the conga line effect. It was much appreciated! I also specifically remember the guy with the pentagram carved into his head. He really put off a "yeah...I'm not going to mess with this dude" vibe. 

There's a plethora of stuff to look at along the way and the lighting is just right to where you can get through without tripping over the uneven ground but still having to really focus and take in everything there is to see. 

Noticeable changes from last year were minimal but as with Zombie City, the environment is a supporting entity to the actors, who are the driving force of this haunt. 

It's also worth mentioning that on special nights, Darkness falls goes completely dark for the Slenderman experience. While we have not experienced it ourselves (but we'd absolutely love to), it sounds incredible. Armed only with a flashlight, a group of 2 people must navigate the trail finding all 8 of the randomly placed papers while avoiding the evil lurking about. 

Lastly, if you haven't seen it, watch "Monsters Wanted" - a documentary about owner Richard Teachout's journey in making Asylum Haunted Screampark a reality. It's free on Amazon Prime Video:

Monsters Wanted - Amazon Prime Video

...and yes, I will watch it very soon Richard. :)

Overall Score - 8.8
Scare Factor - 8
Actors - 10
Visuals - 7.3
Value - 10

Teresa - I love the Culbertson Mansion! The haunt is in the carriage house behind the mansion. That limits the space, but they more than make up for it with creativity and outstanding actors. These two things make this one of my favorite haunts every year. This year the theme is Circus Inferno. They have completely changed the rooms and characters. Starting outside, I saw a couple of my favorite queue actors, Nightmares the clown and this horrifying clown-witch-looking character (is there a name for that phobia?). There's a short outside section with a couple more crazy circus performers that had us laughing right off the bat. Then we went inside. I cannot stress how awesome these actors are. They had great personalities, accents, costumes, and dialogue. I won't tell you all their secrets, but there were creepy crawlers, a very funny fortune teller, a dramatic scene with a high striker strength tester, shrinking walls, a magic show, and the most entertaining chainsaw I've ever seen. We were grinning and laughing through the whole thing. This isn't the scariest haunt I've been to, but it is one of the most fun. The wait isn't long and the price is very good. Highly recommended! Also, go by in the day-time and do a tour of the mansion. Not only is it beautiful, the history is interesting, as are the stories of actual ghosts experienced by caretakers.

Paul - The haunt at Culbertson blew away my expectations. I knew it was a smaller haunt without a huge budget but I loved it! They change the theme of the haunt yearly and this year it's Circus Inferno. Survivors -or not- of a fiery circus train crash are roaming the premises and the carriage house.

Having the lower budget that they do, the only thing you may notice as missing from some of the bigger haunts are the elaborate animatronics and super-detailed sets. Don't get me wrong, it isn't unprofessional at all, it just wasn't the sets that blew me away... It was the actors.  The actors did a fantastic job! They interacted well, they sold their parts, their costumes and makeup were absolutely spot-on, and they made the Culbertson into an amazing experience. And on top of it all, every one of them is there as a volunteer! 

If you're ever in the Louisville area on a night they're open, you really owe it to yourself to visit. It's cheap scary fun, and one of my favorites of the year.

Todd - Just about the only "Con" I can think of when it comes to Literally, A Haunted House at Culbertson Mansion, is that it I wish it was 3 times longer! Culbertson continues to bring an original theme and experience year after year. If you've never been, the haunt resides primarily in the old carriage house behind the historical Culbertson Mansion. Space is very limited so Gary Collins and his crew have a tremendous challenge to keep this haunt fresh each year.

Culbertson outshines many "high dollar" haunts that rely on expensive effects and animatronics for scares, primarily with the drive of their incredible actors (I can't speak highly enough about the actors). They carry an insane amount of energy in their performance and really make the experience stand out. 

The blood, sweat and tears that go into reinventing this haunt each year are clearly evident. While their budget is modest, some of the things they pull off are absent from any other haunts we visit. The originality is off the charts! 

Some attendees may find Culbertson to be a little on the tame side and perhaps turned off by the lack of expensive eye candy other haunts have to offer - and that is a real shame. Culbertson carries with it an "old school" vibe that reminds me of when I was a kid setting up a haunted house in my basement (yes, I was that kid) and dreaming up all of these cool ideas that I had no resources to implement. The passion of haunting lives within Culbertson, which can easily be lost when it comes to developing a high dollar haunt with profit driving decisions.

If you want to feel where haunters' roots are, Culbertson should be your first destination.